Dark clouds in the horizon

The eurozone banks are borrowing heavily from the European Central Bank. Current borrowing amounts to €1,31 trillion. They take the money at negative interest rates, which means that they are paid to borrow. The negative rates are now around minus 1 per cent. By doing so, the ECB is telling us that the funding needs are enormous and that the crisis resulting from the pandemic is very deep.

The picture shows me three more things.

One, that we have too many private banks in the eurozone. Some countries, with small economies, have an incredible number of banking players. Tiny banks are particularly vulnerable to shocks. They represent an additional financial risk at a time of many hazards.

Two, most of the borrowing has been applied by the banks in the purchase of government bonds. That means the ECB is using the commercial houses – and paying them a fee – to finance exceptional and current government expenditures. Public debt is growing fast and in a non-productive way. Its growth goes hand in hand with the tremendous levels of debt of the enterprises and of the poorer segments of the population. Overall debt, in some countries of the zone, is reaching unsustainable levels.

Then, my third point. Conservatives and extreme right parties and movements in richer eurozone States are getting ready to challenge the policy options of the ECB, particularly their easy money funding programmes. These challenges will combine political activism with legal proceedings. As an example, the ultra-nationalist and extremist German party Alternative for Germany has announced today they will move a legal action against the ECB’s emergency programme. It would be a mistake to underestimate this decision. That goes along the recent ruling of the country’s Constitutional Court on a comparable matter. And it must be seen in conjunction with the position that The Netherlands, Finland, and a few others have taken, asking for conditionalities to be added to the Von der Leyen rescue plan.

As I see it, all this contains the seeds for further divisions in Europe. This time, the division might mean severe rupture. It is the future of the Union that is at stake.